Why is Scottish Labour’s civil war missing from the BBC?

dugdale_stvScottish Labour is in crisis.  You might not know it but it is.  There’s a split at the top of the party over the situation regarding Jeremy Corbyn.

Kezia Dugdale has given her public backing to the plotters who are seeking to oust the democratically elected leader of her party.  The Scottish Labour leader is in effect backing mutineers against her boss.

Dugdale though has her own problems.  Her deputy Alex Rowley has refused to support his Scottish boss and has instead publicly attacked the plotters.  Rowley, along with fellow Labour MSPs Neil Findlay and Richard Leonard, are standing four-square behind Corbyn.

On July 1st, the three issued a joint statement in support of Jeremy Corbyn which read:

“Jeremy Corbyn was democratically elected as leader of the Labour Party with almost 60% of members supporting him.

“His campaign succeeded because he offered an alternative to the austerity driven divisions within our economy and society. The events of the last few days have broken the hearts of Labour Party members across the UK.

“Labour Party members are not passive onlookers to be used and exploited at election time, only to be ignored thereafter – they are the lifeblood of our party, we are nothing without them.

“Democracy wherever it is found is a precious thing – we therefore want to make it clear that we wish to uphold the democratic rights of Labour Party members and support the democratically elected leader of the Labour Party, Jeremy Corbyn.”

The statement came days after an announcement from Dugdale that she was giving her support to the plotters.  BBC Scotland cameras were despatched to film the Scottish Labour leader on the day she ‘applied pressure’ to her UK superior.

Dugdale’s undermining of Corbyn was backed by thirteen of her MSPs.  The Labour party has twenty four MSPs at Holyrood.  Even allowing for Rowley, Findlay and Leonard, that leaves eight MSPs unaccounted for.

Scottish Labour is split over the issue of Jeremy Corbyn.  But the split isn’t confined to the Holyrood group of MSPs.  Scottish Labour’s sole MP Ian Murray was attacked by seventy one members of his own local party after he resigned his Shadow Scottish Secretary position.  They accused Murray of ‘disloyalty’ and gave their support to Alex Rowley.  Rowley, it should be remembered, is a close ally of Gordon Brown.

Scottish Labour is in open civil war.  But you wouldn’t know it judging by the near zero coverage of the split on BBC Scotland.  The corporation has barely acknowledged the ‘Corbyn Coup’ has travelled north.  Save for the clip below from Newsdrive on July 1st, there is little coverage of the split.


Kezia Dugdale has faced not one hostile question over the issue.  Repeated requests for interviews have apparently met with refusal from the Scottish Labour leader as the clip below from Good Morning Scotland on July 4th reveals.


The only Scottish Labour MSP who has faced any questions over the Corbyn situation is Neil Findlay who appeared on GMS on July 8th to discuss his new role as convenor of Holyrood’s Health Committee.


Even then, the interviewer failed to press Findlay on the situation within Scottish Labour, preferring instead to ask him whether Jeremy Corbyn should remain – something we already knew the answer to.  Whether Hayley Millar was being steered by someone speaking in her ear we cannot know.  What we do know is that an opportunity to explore the extent of the division within Scottish Labour was wasted.

Dugdale’s refusal to be interviewed is a clear sign that things are not good within Labour’s Scottish branch.  The Sunday Herald newspaper recently claimed that the relationship between her and her deputy had deteriorated to the point where it was non-existent.  Despite this, we have yet to witness anything like the profile and door-stepping that senior SNP politicians always seem to have to endure at the slightest whiff of trouble.

The Scottish Labour civil war is a huge story and follows Dugdale’s disastrous performance during the Scottish election campaign when she led her party to third place behind the SNP and Tories.  Days ago Dugdale floated the idea of Federalism despite having shot-down calls from her deputy for Scottish Labour to adopt a similar stance after the Scottish election humiliation.

Labour is in meltdown in Scotland and our national broadcaster is averting its gaze.  BBC Scotland shows no appetite for pursuing this story.  Just like the ‘PFI Schools scandal’ and broken indyref promises, the culture that has led to a circle of protection of the once dominant party of Scottish politics, remains intact at Pacific Quay.

Things will not get better for Dugdale if, as expected, Corbyn is successful in his bid to appear on the ballot paper.  If the incumbent takes part in a contest with Angela Eagle and Owen Smith, he’ll win hands down.  Kezia Dugdale’s position as leader of the branch party will then be untenable.

Will BBC Scotland wait until the bitter end before giving this story the profile it deserves?  Sadly I think it will.

Edit: Good Morning Scotland presenter Gary Robertson has this morning [Tues July 12th] claimed to have been told by Scottish Labour that Kezia Dugdale is on holiday. Scotland faces being dragged out of the EU, the UK has a new PM and Labour is in civil war north and south of the border. Going on holiday makes Dugdale an even bigger story.


If you enjoyed reading this article then you can make a small donation by clicking the ‘donate’ button below.

Views: 16160
Please follow and like us 🙂

6 thoughts on “Why is Scottish Labour’s civil war missing from the BBC?

  1. Keith Robinson

    Looking at the timing of leadership resignations/nominations/coups, there does seem to be direction from ‘above’ as to how and when events are reported to the public. Nothing is being made of the serious threatening attitude towards Scotland that May has openly stated before she was in the running. Nothing has made of the attempted coup by BBC Scotland.

    Considering the numbers Dugdale’s party DOES not have, I’m surprised they are allowed any airtime at all.

    One thing that is now clearly undeniable; the media is fully capable of setting the pace and the agenda in all matters relating to UK politics. The last bastion of resistance it seems are the grassroots supporters of independence in Scotland. That grassroots support will need to grow stronger if they wish to defeat this neoliberal behemoth in the coming referendum.

  2. Dan Huil

    We all know about the lying britnat media, especially the bbc, which has for years now been in the business of doing down Scotland. Thankfully we have websites like this, but to take on the britnat media we could do with more famous high-profile pro-indy men and women coming out strongly in favour of independence, so strongly that the britnat media can’t ignore them. So strongly that they would be prepared to put their necks on the line. So strongly that they would contemplate breaking the laws of Westminster in order to help the independence movement. How about famous folk publicly declaring they will no longer pay the bbc tax? Or lying down in front of WMD transporters?

  3. FatCandy

    From their statement: “Democracy wherever it is found is a precious thing”.

    Does that mean they’ll support the Scottish Government in their efforts to effect the mandate of the 62% of Scots that voted to remain in the EU?

    Thought not.

  4. millie

    Yes, Scottish labour and also Scottish conservatives are protected by BBC Scotland whenever there is any controversy involving their Westminster MPs. But if there is a hint of anything about an SNP MP- BBC Scotland is in there at speed.

    BBC Scotland is also good at making light of the economic fallout from Brexit (nothing to see here/ Brexit is ‘good’)- They are currently creating the narrative that any problems with the Scottish economy is all about oil and other internal issues. The Call Kaye programme came from Aberdeen (again) this morning- WHY?

    The BBC narrative is to continually focus and reinforce that ‘oil’ is at the heart of Scotland’s economic problems- Also, on the same programme we heard the Fishing Union’s ‘ brexit is good’ mantra. No- one on the programme pointed out that the biggest market for the fish is –Europe- or that in an effort to keep the ‘EU single market’ and gain concessions for the City of London, the UK Government , again, might well negotiate away fishing rights as a bargaining chip.

    As an aside, the Call Kaye Programme today featured;

    David Mundell- Conservative
    Annabelle Goldie – Conservative
    Ian Smart – Labour blogger
    Frank Gilfeather- labour candidate for Holyrood 2016 (North East list)?
    No-one from SNP featured on the programme.

  5. Helen

    Kezia Dugdale is exactly the brand of Labour that Scottish Labour voters left Labour in droves to the SNP. The people of Scotland don’t want Tory Lite, they want a credible opposition to Austerity and the Neo-Liberal consensus of the past 30 years. Labour got complacent in Scotland and took their eye off the ball with their Labour voters iand they have paid a heavy price. They would do well now, to emulate Jeremy Corbyn and maybe, just maybe, they will get back some of their previous success in Scotland, but I wouldn’t hold my breath, if they continue to mimic the Tories they will never have a future in Scotland. xxxxx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com