Tory Minister’s ‘Rape Clause’ comments edited out of Reporting Scotland

Controversial comments from a UK Government minister that described the so-called ‘Rape Clause’ as an “opportunity” for victims of rape to talk about their ordeal, have been edited out of BBC Scotland’s flagship news programme Reporting Scotland.

Appearing before the Scottish Parliament’s Social Security Committee on Monday, UK minister Esther McVey was asked whether she was comfortable with a rape victim having to prove she was raped in order to receive benefits.

The Tory MP defended the so-called ‘Rape Clause’ insisting it was providing “extra help”, before adding: “… people will be supported and shown to the various other organisations.

“And again this could give them an opportunity to talk about maybe something that’s happened that they never had before.

“So it is potentially double support there, them getting the money they need and maybe an outlet which they might possibly need.”

However when the item aired on that evening’s Reporting Scotland, the controversial comments from the Tory MP were missing from the programme.  Viewers heard McVey’s initial response to Green MSP Alison Johnstone before the video was abruptly cut, the recording resumed briefly with protests being heard from the public gallery.

Presenting the news report was BBC Scotland reporter Glenn Campbell.  The reporter’s subdued analysis of the exchanges was the subject of criticism online with some commentators accusing the BBC Scotland reporter of repeating Tory party claims whilst ignoring well-documented criticism of the ‘Rape Clause’ from respected organisations.

One social media user said: “Love Glenn repeating Tory DWP claims without the slightest attempt at him doing his job as a journalist and investigating whether they are true or not. Not even so much as a “…but critics say” or any mention of such critics of Tory DWP policy as the United Nations or UNICEF.”

Another lamented the state of BBC Scotland: “What an outlet, it’s horrific that people require to complete a form to say they been raped and conceived a child. What disgusting barbaric behaviour. Clear to this day, to be a Conservative you clearly have a piece of your humanity and soul missing.”

The Tory policy has already been described as ‘shameful’ by the British Medical Association.

The comments from McVey were described by First Minister Nicola Sturgeon as “outrageous”.

The SNP leader was responding to a tweet posted by the Editor of Holyrood magazine Mandy Rhodes who herself appeared shocked by the Tory MP’s comments.

SNP MSP Gillian Martin tweeted: “Esther McVey’s words here beggar belief. She’s trying to pass off the Tory rape clause as “an opportunity”. No wonder the public gallery was in uproar. Absolutely disgraceful.”

The decision by Reporting Scotland to edit out McVey’s controversial comments will come as no surprise to many pro-independence critics of BBC Scotland.  The corporation has faced a string of complaints over the pro-Ruth nature of its Scottish political output from viewers north of the border.  The BBC continually refuses to accept there is anything wrong with its Scottish political output.

Indyref2 would like to do more news pieces. Feel free to make a contribution towards this goal.




Views: 7054
Please follow and like us 🙂

7 thoughts on “Tory Minister’s ‘Rape Clause’ comments edited out of Reporting Scotland

  1. scrandoonyeah

    My heart sinks at the inhumanity and stupidity of this woman and my head rages at the BBC in its smug biased reporting.

  2. Robert Graham

    What is it with Women in the tory party , most of the men are just plain stupid , but the Women are on an entirely different level they are evil , it started with Thatcher the woman who destroyed communities all over the country , have a look at the tory MSPs every one bundle of Joy ,just waiting to make someone’s life a little worse than it was yesterday , vomit inducing vermin and thats being nice in the description of them .

  3. Jockanese Wind Talker

    BritNat Broadcasting Corporation employees (especially those who exercise editorial control) should ponder the Nuremberg Trials

    “Among the defendants were two individuals linked to the creation or dissemination of Nazi propaganda. The cases against Der Stürmer’s editor Julius Streicher, and Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda official Hans Fritzsche rested entirely upon their actions as propagandists. The indictment included the statement that propaganda was “one of the strongest weapons of the conspirators [who] from the outset…appreciated the urgency of the task of inculcating the German masses with the National Socialist principles and ideology,” and who used propaganda “to prepare the ground psychologically for political action and military aggression.””

    They appear to be doing/have done the same for “psychological groundwork” for The UK Governments illegal military intervention in Iraq and now Syria.

    Only difference is that they won’t end up in The Hague.

    1. Jockanese Wind Talker

      Now let’s look at that statement in regard to BritNat Broadcasting Corporations systematic monstering of The Democratically elected Scottish Government:

      “Among the defendants were individuals linked to the creation or dissemination of Unionist propaganda. The cases against BBC Scotlands editors rested entirely upon their actions as propagandists. The indictment included the statement that propaganda was “one of the strongest weapons of the conspirators [who] from the outset…appreciated the urgency of the task of inculcating the Scottish masses with the British Nationalist Unionist principles and ideology,” and who used propaganda “to prepare the ground psychologically for political action.”

      Aye the incessant “Scotland Shite ‘cos EssEnnPeeBaaaad” Soft Coup stuff fits the bill IMHO.

  4. Alasdair Macdonald

    The programme focussed on the protests from the gallery and the decision by the convenor twice to halt proceedings. The interruption as an interruption per se became the point of the report rather than the appallingly insensitive comments of the minister.

  5. millie

    A piece of gold plated smearing innuendo re Cambridge Analytica on BBC Politics Scotland today – well done Ivan McKee in dealing with it.

    Brewer and Brian Taylor were having a hoot about it. Why is BBC Scotland not questioning Labour, Liberals and Conservatives to obtain full details of their dealings with CA?

    As an aside, it is curious that when questioned by Brendan O’Hara at Westminster, the female from CA decided to single out and ‘name’ the SNP. NO, actually it is not curious – intentional.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com