Scottish Tory MP ridiculed over Scottish Fire Service VAT claim

A Scottish Conservative MP as been ridiculed on social media after bizarrely claiming her party ended an “SNP policy” that forced the Scottish Fire Service to pay VAT.

In her tweet, Kirstene Hair MP said: “Fire crews across the UK are already stretched by the hot dry weather – the last thing they need is an increase in malicious fires. Thankfully, @ScotTories ended the SNP policy that saw our fire service pay VAT – the £10 million saved could pay for an extra 350 firefighters.”

The claim prompted angry responses on social media, with many people pointing out the VAT charge on Scottish emergency services was in fact Tory policy.

SNP MSP Michael Russell tweeted: “I presume the assertion regarding VAT is because @Kirstene4Angus has misunderstood the matter – this article from the Herald may help her. After reading it she will, I hope, delete the reference, unless she actively intends to spread completely fake news.”

SNP MSP Michael Matheson tweeted: “It was also debated in Parliament back in October 2017, with support from all parties…..with the exception of the Tories.”

In October 2017, Ruth Davidson’s MSPs refused to back a motion calling on the UK Government to scrap the policy that prevented Police Scotland and the Scottish Fire and Rescue from reclaiming VAT.  During the Holyrood debate, Scottish Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser said there was “no justification for a VAT refund” for Police Scotland and Scotland’s Fire Service.

A sustained campaign started by the SNP in 2012 eventually led to the UK Government announcing a U-turn on the policy in November 2017.

The policy change meant Police Scotland and the Scottish Fire Service were able to reclaim an estimated £35m annually.

Responding to Kirstene Hair’s bid to claim credit, SNP MSP Paul Wheelhouse tweeted: “I am weighing up whether you believe VAT remark to be true, in which case your research skills are beneath the standard required for an MP, or whether you are deliberately misleading your constituents. Either way, not a good look.”


Indyref2 would like to do more news pieces. Feel free to make a contribution towards this goal.

Views: 8431
Please follow and like us 🙂

3 thoughts on “Scottish Tory MP ridiculed over Scottish Fire Service VAT claim

  1. John

    This is a victory the Tories in Scotland have claimed as their own , they claim it was their negotiations at Westminster that got rid of VAT payments from Police Scotland and the Fire Service . Not true , SNP MP’S had been fighting for a refund of VAT since they went to Westminster in 2015 but no-one was listening to them , as on so many other things . The reason that Westminster changed their minds on the VAT payments was purely political . It was done to make it look as if the new intake of Tories from Scotland were achieving things at Westminster . Not true , the Tories in Scotland have achieved absolutely nothing for Scotland at Westminster except to constantly talk Scotland down ! .

  2. Robert

    The stupid SNP were well warned when they first
    organised Police Scotland and the fire service
    They were told governments cannot claim VAT back but they went ahead.
    They moaned and bitched when they realised after the event it was going to happen
    If the truth be told it was David Mundell who helped restore the VAT to the services
    and hes a conservative
    Really I despair with this Silly Scottish governemtn
    get them out next election they have done little for Scotland we are a laughing stock

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By :