Reporting Scotland – A bad joke worthy of our contempt

reporting_scotlandI stopped watching Reporting Scotland live some time ago.  Instead I wait until it appears on iPlayer and then skim through the programme to see what was reported.

That way I don’t have to waste a full half an hour watching the god-awful programme, but I can still observe the political manipulation that takes place.

I have nothing but contempt for the production team that produce this colonial pip-squeak show.  A diet of death & football, garnished with exaggerated parochial bullshit is as far from a national news programme as it is possible to get.

Have you ever seen Scotland portrayed in a good light when watching this programme?  Think about it.  What image of this great nation does Reporting Scotland project?

Two weeks ago I watched in dismay as a world first in renewable technology was relegated to the arse-end of the programme.  Shetland was the location for the first offshore tidal array in the world to deliver electricity to the grid.  The feel-good story had everything; technological innovation, Scottish engineering, world first in Green Energy and the possibility of thousands of jobs.

Renewable energy is a fledgling sector in Scotland.  Our potential in this sector is absolutely mind-bogglingly massive.  Yet the story was kicked into the Reporting Scotland dead-zone behind a twenty year old murder, a bizarre report from Serbia about refugees, another murder, Curriculum for Excellence, drunk airline pilots and the Edinburgh Festival.

When it aired at last, this technological success story ran for a mere thirty eight seconds.  Below is the full item.

The story was buried.  That it was even squeezed out by two inebriated airline pilots summed up the mindset of those who produce this nightly reminder of a pre-devolution Scotland.

Reporting Scotland isn’t a window into modern Scotland.  It’s a distorted mirror framed by a once hidden, but now exposed, anachronistic pro-Union template.  The Scotland we are presented with each evening is a Scotland that oozes violence, whose institutions are falling apart, whose government is dictatorial and whose ambition must be thwarted.  It screams ‘know your place’.

The tidal turbines are a metaphor for the emerging Scotland.  They are a success story.  They also draw attention to the vast renewable energy that is waiting to be tapped once Scotland gains full control over its resources.

It’s everything that BBC Scotland isn’t.  The only way the turbines would ever have received high-profile coverage is if something went wrong.

Tidal turbines had a second chance to make it as a major news item this week when the First Minister herself attended the official unveiling of the MeyGen project that will see the first turbines to be installed in the Pentland Firth.  This project is absolutely massive with plans for 269 huge turbines, each 15m tall and weighing 200 tons, generating enough electricity to power 175,000 homes.

So where in the list of priority was this story placed?  First, second, third, fourth, fifth? … in fact the story was relegated to fifteenth place in order of priority.  That’s right, there were fourteen stories covered before we got to the tidal turbines.  The clip below contains the introduction of each story in the order each appeared.

When it finally aired the turbines story was allotted 1 minute 45 seconds.  Viewers did get to hear the First Minister speak and there were impressive graphics of the turbines [courtesy of the manufacturer] but again a major good news story of national significance was relegated below other items of dubious newsworthiness.

It was the same the following evening when the programme again prioritised its news stories in a highly questionable manner.  The two biggest stories to break that day were based on newly published reports.  The first showed Scotland to be ahead of the rest of the UK in terms of climate change targets.  The second was from the Fraser of Allander Institute that showed Scotland’s real terms grant from Westminster had been cut by five per cent since 2010 with a projected cut to the Scottish budget that could reach £1.6 billion by 2021.

So a news story favourable to the Scottish government and one unfavourable to the UK government, and by extension bad news for Unionists.  So where did these two stories feature?

The top three stories on Reporting Scotland were Schools, a murder trial and Ebola nurse Pauline Cafferkey.  So neither story was considered important enough to be included in the top three items.

The climate change story was relegated to fourth spot.  The item focused not on the good news aspects of the report but on the negatives, such as transport.  There then followed another murder story and another item on the tragic death of the five year old boy from Shettleston the previous day.

The cut to the Scottish budget was the seventh item on Reporting Scotland.  Now I ask you to pause for a moment to think about that.  Here is a key element in the debate over Scotland’s constitutional future.  The relative well-being of Scotland within the Union currently dominates that debate, yet a projected cut to Scotland’s budget is relegated to seventh place on BBC Scotland’s flagship news programme.

Contrast this with the coverage afforded the GERS report when it was published weeks ago.  It was the lead item on Reporting Scotland and dominated that day’s news.  GERS of course presented figures that, on the surface at least, appeared challenging to the independence movement.

A considerable cut to the Holyrood budget within the Union presents a challenge to those Unionists who argued we were ‘Better Together’.  But there were no questions for people like David Mundell or indeed any of the Better Together pack who sold us the ‘Better Together’ line.

But that wasn’t all.  Take a look at the presentation of this news by Reporting Scotland.

Rather than paint the cut to the Scottish budget as bad news for Unionism, it is instead manipulated into a council election issue.  Sally McNair introduces the item with the following statement.

“The squeeze on Holyrood’s budget is likely to dominate the council elections next May as the amount councillors have to spend could be cut by as much as a billion pounds over the next four years.”

What is happening here is that the viewer is being led away from the idea that London is to blame for cuts to services.  The blame will instead fall on the shoulders of the Scottish government – in short the SNP.  Note the reference to the council tax freeze by Douglas Fraser and the continual reference to the SNP.  The Scottish Labour party has been pushing this line for years.  They’ll be fighting next year’s council elections using it – it looks like BBC Scotland is preparing the ground.

At the end of the clip you’ll have seen Gary Robertson plugging Scotland 2016, a programme that was resurrected Lazarus like by BBC Scotland after the shock of Brexit.  I had a quick look on iPlayer when drafting this article and can sadly report nothing has changed.  There were two Unionists pitched against the solitary SNP guest in a studio debate.   Unionism is still over-represented.

Below is how Gary Robertson introduced the programme and the subsequent imbalanced debate which favoured Unionist parties by two-to-one [remember that pro-indy parties have a small majority at Holyrood].

Of course it isn’t just the prioritising of news stories that has earned BBC Scotland’s flagship evening news programme the derogatory nickname ‘Distorting Scotland’.  The programme is also famed for its failure to report political stories.

Last Thursday First Minister Nicola Sturgeon called on Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson to apologise after the Tory MSP’s party had issued what was described by critics as a xenophobic attack on a French born former SNP MSP Christian Allard.  Allard had reported Tory MSP Alexander Burnett to the Standards Commissioner for failing to disclose business interests when raising objections against a rival businessman in the Scottish Parliament.

The Tory press office responded with a statement which said: “Some people may find it bizarre that an EU citizen has an interest in a planning application in Banchory.  However, it is easily explained when people understand that the planning consultant in question is an SNP appointee to the Scottish Government housing committee and Christian Allard was a former SNP MSP.”

Despite the First Minister publicly calling on Davidson to apologise during First Minister’s Questions, the story was ignored by Reporting Scotland.  Indeed I can find no evidence that BBC Scotland reported the issue anywhere on its media platform.

This weekend Nicola Sturgeon sent a letter to Davidson reiterating her demands for an apology.  BBC Scotland ignored the issue again.

On Tuesday the issue escalated when the Consular Councillor for French Nationals intervened and sent his own letter to the Scottish Conservative leader demanding an apology.  Again there was nothing on BBC Scotland’s flagship evening news programme.

I haven’t had time to observe all news output on BBC Scotland.  However it does appear that Ruth Davidson’s refusal to apologise for a rather unfortunate choice of words issued on behalf of her party has been ignored by BBC Scotland.

Is it news?  Well yes if you believe STV and a host of other media outlets including the Daily Record which have carried the story.

The intervention by the Consular Councillor for French Nationals should have merited considerable coverage by Reporting Scotland.  How so?  Well cast your mind back to the referendum campaign and an interview given by Alex Salmond to a London based magazine.  Comments from the then First Minister about Vladimir Putin were manipulated by a corrupt media and resulted in demands for an apology from opposition leaders.

On April 29th 2014 a spokesman for Ukrainians in Scotland sent a letter to the First Minister demanding an apology.  The letter was the top story on that evening’s Reporting Scotland.

The story ran for weeks, from April and into June.  Salmond was relentlessly pursued by the BBC over an innocuous remark.


There’s been no such pursuit of Ruth Davidson over an alleged xenophobic statement issued by her party.  At a time when foreign nationals in the UK are concerned about an increase in racist attacks due to Brexit, the story is very highly topical.  Ironically a nurse [Pauline Cafferkey] who put her own life in peril when she volunteered to go to Sierra Leone to help Ebola victims has endured more critical coverage courtesy of BBC Scotland than Ruth Davidson.

This article is a mere snapshot of what passes for news on Reporting Scotland and what doesn’t.  The questionable prioritisation and effective blackouts has been going for years.  Like many people I’ve lost all faith in the people who are producing this stuff.

I still support a Scottish Six in principle and the full devolution of broadcasting to Scotland whilst we remain part of the Union.  However there’s no doubt in my mind that whether in or out of this Union, we need a complete clearout of management within the News and Current Affairs department at Pacific Quay.  It’s rotten.

If you enjoyed reading this article please feel free to make a small donation.

Views: 21464
Please follow and like us 🙂

16 thoughts on “Reporting Scotland – A bad joke worthy of our contempt

  1. Ian

    Thanks for an excellent article. I have opted out of watching this stuff – but this is just a reminder of insidious twisting that is going on. Your evidenced based approach is really valuable and greatly appreciated.

  2. Dan Huil

    I commend GAP and others for still having the stomach to watch this disgrace of a news programme and subjecting the never-ending anti-Scottish bias to scrutiny.

    All I can say, again, to those like me, is, do not pay the bbc tax. The bbc will only take notice if it is suffering financially.

    Also, apparently people are now supposed to pay the bbc tax even if they only watch its programmes via the internet. Again: don’t pay. If most of us refuse to pay for internet access it will be impossible for the bbc to do anything about it.

  3. Kevin Taylor

    Brilliant, once more, from GAP. However he seems to be one of the very few prominent voices exposing the constant tyranny of the BBC. I’m wondering, just when will our Scottish voice newspaper – The National – have a pop at them? The evidence is irrefutable, overwhelming and on a daily-basis, and unless you’re a regular Twitter user, this anti-Scots racist nonsense will never be seen.

    We could certainly do with a rebuke – even a couple per week – from ‘the newspaper that supports an independent Scotland’. How about it, The National? How about an all-singing and dancing front-page portrayal of Ms Bird and others as bloody-well lying to the people of Scotland? We’ll buy that headline, we’ll pay for that newspaper, we’ll support that bold journalism that’ll cut through the deceit.
    No? I damn-well guessed not.

    1. Andy Borland

      I agree, it would be an excellent idea for the National.

      A weekly piece, entitled Distorting Scotland, highlighting just like GA does manfully here, the national disgrace that is Reporting Scotland.

      Come on George, pitch them yourselves!

    2. Mike McCann

      The National is just the flip side of the BBC coin. Don’t see you composing about their stance. Just because the BBC has a crap editorial team, it doesn’t mean that it is anti the SNP. It’s colours are firmly nailed to a left-wing mast.

      1. George

        The National isn’t the flip side of the BBC it’s the flip side of the Record or Herald. It’s entitled to a skewed editorial stance just like any newspaper. The BBC has no such entitlement. It’s governed by strict impartiality rules.

  4. John Docherty

    Biased news . Removal of the saltire .from Scottish produce,the butchers apron in almost every program,subliminal British adverts popping up in shopping centres ? Still don’t know what’s goining on ? We must get the truth out there ,if we are to persuade don’t knows,of the Justis of our cause,an Independent Scotland ,standing proud on the World stage. ?

  5. George boyd

    I still watch reporting Scotland evening news – know your enemy – and I also could not believe how the positive news on climate change was turned into a negative by the use of the transport side of the debate. The unionist propaganda arm at Pacific Quay is well past its sell by date and needs consigned to the dustbin of history.

  6. henry docherty

    The drip drip drip of negative stories and ignoring the great things happening in Scotland is all designed to undermine confidence.

    This is why I call it “Retarding Scotland”.

  7. Philip Maughan

    The Pentland Firth story was one of a number of potentially very exciting developments which went unreported. In addition was the major oil find West of Shetland (reported in the National by George Kerevan) and the electricity storage system being piloted on Ghigha to capture the wind generated energy for use during non-producing periods.

  8. Paula Kelly

    The whole thing is a Joke, from the BBC to Mainstream News papers to
    West minster and the House of Lords, none of which serve Scotland’s
    people and culture or interests.

    Enough is enough.

    The very ones that controlled ( Ruled ) the so called “United Kingdom”
    have all ran away ?

    Surely Scotland, this is now our chance to be FREE ! and show this world
    what we’re all about. E.g. Invention, Tourism, Renewable Energy, Exports/Imports,
    Immigration ( both to work and seek solitude ) Compassion, Creativity, Water, Oil
    the list goes on and on.

    Let’s give it a go, I’d rather we made a mistake or two under. Scottish Rule than some
    other System who has never cared for Scotland and only drained her resources for
    thier own gain for far too long.

    E.g Oil and fishery borders ( Decided by Westminster )

    Trident, Nuclear weapon dumped in Scotland, against every Scottish persons wishes
    ( Decided by Westminster )

    Oh and the little detail of going to war in the Middle East at the drop of a hat, Against
    every Scottish persons wishes, again and again. ( Decided by Westminster )

    Hmmmm, isn’t what one accepts as reality pathetic sometimes ?

  9. millie

    This is a bit off topic, but I don’t expect it will be covered on Reporting Scotland.

    I don’t know if it has been shared, as I don’t have Facebook or Twitter- but the whole article makes for very interesting reading vis a vis Scotland’s Brexit situation. As an aside, the sheer amount of positive coverage of Sadiq Khan in this newspaper highlights just how little coverage Nicola Sturgeon receives.

    ‘’Sadiq Khan today confirmed that City Hall is working on a separate London work permit system for when Britain leaves the EU.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By :