Good Will Shall be Scotland’s Salvation in Europe

I hope most Scots appreciate how kindly they are viewed by much of the world. I’m sure any of you who have gone abroad discern the much more favourable reaction you get when they realize you’re Scottish, and not merely British, as they swoon over your cool accent. In my Political Science class here in Brittany last week, the students were completely with the Scots in their desire to stay in Europe, as they couldn’t stand the attitude of the English. While the British ‘brand’ has overshadowed Scottishness until now, you can rest assured that Scots have engendered a great deal of good will in the world.

This good will is about to pay off in spades in the Brexit negotiation. Just after the vote in June, Nicola Sturgeon flew to Brussels and met with Jean Claude Juncker head of the European Commission and Martin Schultz President of the European Parliament. She was warmly greeted and listened to about her desire to keep as close ties as possible with Europe, whatever happens with Brexit.

Then, in late June, we heard this resounding exhortation from MEP Alyn Smith.

Compare this the EU Parliament reaction to Nigel Farage.

Since then, Nicola Sturgeon has proven to be the most competent and respected politician in the UK, or the English-speaking world for that matter. She has tirelessly explored all options to assure Scotland’s place within the EU, with independence being the final option if no other viable path can be found.

This positive and cooperative attitude is why Scotland has so much good will, which will help immensely for Scotland to secure independence within the EU, and eventually replace the UK as a member state.

Meanwhile in Westminster, the chickens are coming to roost in Big Ben, and it is beginning to dawn on them what a monumental blunder Brexit is. While Brexiteers for months have been prancing about exhorting cake possession and ingestion, and all the rinky-dink trade deals they could sign after leaving the most successful one in the world, the last few days have revealed how costly and economically devastating the divorce will be.

The agenda for the divorce will be set by the EU. A ‘good deal’ is not on the menu. First on the list is the bills for what the UK has already committed to, pension liabilities and the like, which looks to be an eye-watering €50 billion. Well, at least the UK has its sovereignty back.

Despite all the talk of the ‘plans’ the UK government is cooking up as to their future relationship with the EU, within recent days any fairy tales about the UK getting the ‘best deal for Britain’ have come crashing down to earth. There is no way during the 2 year period there can be both a divorce and a new trade deal, largely because the terms of divorce must be settled before there is a basis upon which to negotiate a new trade deal. It will likely take another decade to negotiate another trade deal, if the EU even wants to bother. They may want to get some rest after 18 months in a room with David Davis and Boris Johnson having to smell their farts.

The most destructive thing that the UK government has done since the Brexit vote has been displaying its attitude of contempt and arrogance towards the process. Just after the vote, there was some good will towards the UK and a desire to make it work as well as possible. Then, Boris Johnson gets chosen as Foreign Minister, Nigel Farage keeps hanging around Brussels and insulting them, and the UK keeps acting as if it has the upper hand, as if the EU wouldn’t dare give them a bad deal. Something about upsetting German car makers.

This blithely arrogant and contemptuous tone of the UK has withered any potential will to help Britain through this smoothly, and the EU 27 are more united than ever in preserving Europe and not giving the UK a deal that would encourage others to leave. That means full divorce, and they’ll see about a trade deal after. Optimistically in 12 years, the UK may be close to the same trading deal it has right now.

We also learned that Scotland will take part of the divorce proceedings, which confirms that the EU will cooperate in helping Scotland remain in the EU to the highest degree possible, perhaps as an independent state. Given all of the scenarios such as ‘reverse Greenland’ or joining the EFTA, Scotland becoming independent would be the easiest and most elegant solution. If Scotland becomes independent, this will have to be factored into the divorce proceedings. Perhaps it will be less expensive for the r-UK if Scotland and Northern Ireland separate from the UK and remain in the EU. The UK, the EU, Scotland, and likely Northern Ireland and the Republic will jointly negotiate the post-Brexit constitutional future of the British Isles.

Scotland is only in this position because of the good will it has built up, and the positive attitude Scots have exhibited in the EU project as evinced by their overwhelming vote to stay in. During the 2014 referendum campaign, Scots were constantly told they would be thrown out of the EU if they left the UK, and they would have to get to the back of the queue behind Kosovo to join. There was much sympathy throughout Europe for Scotland’s position and desire to retain them within the EU had they voted ‘yes’, but no member state could openly endorse Scottish independence.

Brexit turns this on its head. It also demonstrates that the EU membership is about much more than treaty requirements. At the end of the day, it is a political organization composed of human beings. They don’t want to expel good EU citizens and nations; it would be suicidal. While Madrid’s hair is on fire shrieking that only member states can negotiate and that Scotland must leave with the r-UK, the EU will be sitting down with Scotland to discuss its constitutional future. This demonstrates pragmatism over treaty rigidity, and gives hope to the Catalans as well.

Mark my words. Scotland will soon be a proud independent member of the European family of nations. The beauty of the Scots character has seen to it.

Please follow and like us 🙂

11 thoughts on “Good Will Shall be Scotland’s Salvation in Europe

  1. Gordoz

    This is welcome news Mark.
    Glad to hear our European cousins can make the distinction between scot & Brit
    Wish more here at home could also see the benefit of such clarity.

  2. Willie John

    This goodwill is not new. Back in the early 80’s I was in Germany attached to the army and we were issued fuel vouchers to use at the local garages. However as not all garages would accept them we had to ask if they would take them before pumping petrol. At one garage when I went to the kiosk I was told they could not accept the vouchers, but as I turned to leave I heard one German say to his mate (in german, of course) ‘damned Englander’. I went back and in my own excruciating German told them I was not a damned Englander, but a damned Scot!

    By the time I got back to the car they were out the door after me saying they could accept the vouchers after all, and apologising if they had insulted me!

  3. Clydebuilt

    Felt better after reading this…… Good positive insight.

    I often think that the Tories have no intention of a hard Brexit, has it all just been posturing to attract wayward Ukipper’s back to the fold…. Hoping at the last minute the courts or parliament will stop a hard Brexit….. The Tories will put their arms up shouting we tried our best.

    Can’t see them putting the wishes of Labour voting Northern English ahead of their precious City.

    1. Sandy

      As per my comment on a previous post. I think the Tories are arrogant enough to believe their own BS, they are afraid of the fallout if they don’t now deliver Brexit and they are afraid the EU would act like they would and remove rebates/vetos/opt-outs from the UK if it backed down and tried to stay in the EU.

  4. bringiton

    I have no doubt that Westminster will try to veto Scotland having any independent attachment to Europe (or anyone else for that matter) and I do believe that a large part of the delay in them getting on with the divorce is their desire,above all else,to hang onto us.
    We are their prized possession and they will not give it up easily.

    1. Alasdair Macdonald

      I think this is something that we, as supporters of independence, need to become more explicit about, indeed, put the unionists in the position of having to state why Scotland should remain part of the UK.

      If we are a ‘basket case’, if we are ‘subsidy junkies’, if we are ‘too wee and no good enough’ to survive on our own, then why should the rUK continue to pour money into Scotland? Would it not be better for rUK to declare its independence from us?

      ‘Better Together’ was couched in these dependency terms, the ‘pooling and sharing’, we were told, mainly being shared by England, and London and the South East in particular. It was the NOers who were grovelling, yet they tried to portray YES as the supplicants.

  5. Graham Rae

    ‘Since then, Nicola Sturgeon has proven to be the most competent and respected politician in the UK, or the English-speaking world for that matter.’ Careful, we don’t want to get into excessive hyperbole, or Cult of Personality. These things can interfere with how a person or politician is viewed, and uncritical thinking can be dangerous, She doesn’t walk on water. Nobody does.

    Just a thought.

  6. Adrian Logstone

    Some mischevious EU politicians like Junker may indulge Scotland just to get at the UKG, but don’t make the mistake of thinking that they give toss about us. As far as most of Europe is concerned we’re the northern tip of a small damp island in the North Sea.

    1. Lawrence Anderson Burley

      Not so sure about that. It’s the northern tip of a damp island that happens to be in pole strategic position controlling the North Atlantic, with some of the best fish stocks in Europe, the most powerful wind and wave renewable energy, world class universities, an engineering tradition second to none, a flourishing agri and food & bev industry, oil & gas still exploitable, a world wide diaspora that strongly identifies with the auld country…

      A definite plus for an EU in need of success stories.

      There is real respect for Scotland. I am of an age (60++!) and a background (Scots / Belgian-French who lived half his youth in Flanders and France) that absorbed when young the importance and high status accorded on the continent to culture, literature and enlightenment philosophy. It is still the case. Thatcherite destruction of society has not prevailed across the water. Scotland scores high and recent events have but increased the score.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By :