I suppose it was inevitable that the British media would find something in the ‘Panama Papers’ affair that they could weave into their campaign to portray Scotland as some kind of lawless hell-hole.

Don’t get me wrong! I have no doubt that the situation regarding Scottish company law and SLPs is, at least approximately, as claimed. Given that this is yet another area of legislation which is reserved to Westminster, one would expect it to be dubious, if not actually corrupt. But that’s a separate issue. What I find offensive is the eagerness and unconcealed glee with which the mouthpieces of the British establishment pounce on anything that can be spun into another gobbet of anti-Scottish propaganda. What rankles is the way in which even the most tenuous opportunity is seized upon for the purpose of denigrating Scotland.

There’s one of those ‘fine lines’ involved here. The line that separates justifiable criticism and revelations that are undoubtedly in the public interest from a decidedly malicious political agenda. Which side of that line articles such as this fall on is, of course, largely a matter of perception. But if that perception is open enough to take in the wider context of mainstream media messages relating to Scotland, it is very difficult indeed to avoid recognising a pattern of belittling and besmirching and defaming such as one would hardly find in the national media of any other country.

The print media in particular is nothing if not Janus-faced. On those all-too-frequent occasions when that fateful combination of manipulative power and towering self-righteousness leads to conduct so reprehensible as to prompt calls for regulation, they will take up the shield of moral obligation and the sword of public service to defend ‘freedom of expression’. Or, to put it another way, their ‘right’ to act with impunity. Their ‘freedom’ to behave irresponsibly or despicably without being held to account.

But, when criticised for partiality or for distorting facts to serve some partisan agenda, they will immediately disclaim any moral responsibility. They will hide behind the defence that they are merely businesses trying to sell a product, with no duty to the public or to democracy or to truth.

The question that consumers of media messages must ask themselves is how much confidence they can have in organs with such an ambivalent, self-serving attitude to anything we might recognise as professional standards or an ethical code.

Views: 3748

Please follow and like us 🙂

4 thoughts on “Depressing

  1. John

    Absolutely agree Peter, and it is constant , and it has got worse in the last few months . I used to think it was just a game to them but I now have come to the conclusion that it is far more sinister than we think . How can it be that every newspaper in the UK is so vehemently anti Scottish ,they miss no opportunity to slap Scotland in the face . How can it be we have a national broadcaster that berates everything the SNP government does , at every level .How can it be that Scotland has no champions out there putting out the positives , are they being denied the chance , is there no public platform they are allowed to inhibit . There is united vile out there and it is worrying , this kind of behaviour leads to discontent and anarchy , is that their end game ?.

  2. Colin

    And you wonder where the Scottish cringe came from. Generation after generation having this put to then in a daily basis. Thank God folk are wishing up to it.

  3. Corrado Mella

    The BritNat beast is wounded, scared, weaker by the minute and bewildered that everything is slipping away in a haze.

    The wildebeest is fighting for its survival: the more blood it sees the harder it lashes, unaware that the blood is gushing from its heart.

    Hold the fort and prepare for the worst Scotland, for our freedom will cost dear.

  4. Mike

    While we all recognise the timing of this growth of demeaning all that is Scottish shows its shallowness, none the less it is wearing and I for one will be glad when this election is over (until the next one), when we can get on with Scotland doing better than it has ever done in my lifetime. A louder and more obvious voice in Westminster and the uniqueness of a Scotland focused party in Government.

    Regardless of whether you are pro or anti SNP, you cannot deny that they are focused squarely on Scotland; unlike Tory, Labour or Lib Dem denigrators, whose only focus is what suits their parties’ London centric agendas.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By :