By their words shall you know them

It is all too easy to simply dismiss anything that David Mundell says. He has no legitimacy. He has no credibility. His office is a sick joke at the expense of democracy and the people of Scotland. And his nickname is ‘Snackbeard’.

He has no mandate. He does not speak for Scotland. The pretence that he is Scotland’s voice in the British cabinet fools only those who choose to be fooled. Most recognise him as the agent in Scotland of a government which we decisively and repeatedly rejected at the polls but which nonetheless asserts the right to impose on us policies that we abhor while treating our democratically elected representatives with undisguised contempt.

And his nickname is ‘Snackbeard’.

But it is precisely because he is the British state’s man in the north that we should attend to what he says. For in his words we will find clues to the concerns and purposes of British establishment. When, for example, Mundell talks of Nicola Sturgeon using the Brexit process to “leverage the argument for Scottish independence” we should not discount it as empty rhetoric, but should look for the meaning and intent behind the words. Which is not to say that we should accept his perspective or his assessment. That would be an even greater folly than disregarding him completely. If a British nationalist politician says the First Minister is doing something then the default assumption always should be that this is not the thing that she is doing, but the thing that the British political elite wants people to believe she is doing.

Nicola Sturgeon is most certainly NOT using the Brexit process to “leverage the argument for Scottish independence”. In fact, she is going to great lengths to avoid even the perception that she might be doing so. Because she is perfectly well aware that nothing would more surely sour the relationship that she is seeking to build with the EU than the impression that she was using Brexit for her own political purposes. She knows that the rapport she is seeking will be impossible if she is thought to be insincere in her commitment to Europe.

Of course, Mundell and his bosses are also aware of this. Which is precisely why he has been instructed to say what he is saying. It’s all about planting seeds of discord. It’s about driving a wedge between the Scottish Government and EU leaders. It has absolutely nothing to do with securing the interests of the people of Scotland. It’s the old British strategy of divide and rule. It’s the dogma of ‘The Union At Any Cost!’.

Don’t ignore Mundell. Whatever your natural inclination may be, listen to what he says. You can be sure it will tell you a lot more about him and the British nationalist mindset than it will about the SNP or the wider independence movement in Scotland. Listen carefully when he describes Nicola Sturgeon as being a “prisoner of her own party”. Think about that. What does it mean? Does it not imply that Mundell is offended by the fact that Sturgeon is doing what she and her party have been mandated to do? In what sense might she be a “prisoner of her own party” other than in the sense of doing the bidding of its 125,000 members; adhering to the policy agenda that they helped formulate; and honouring the manifesto endorsed by Scotland’s electorate?

What do Snackbeard’s own words tell us about his attitude to Scotland, its people and democracy?

Views: 3815

Many thanks to everyone who has been kind enough to make a donation.
Your generosity is quite extraordinary, and very much appreciated.
All monies received are used in furtherance of the campaign
to restore Scotland’s rightful constitutional status.
Please use the button below or click here.



Please follow and like us 🙂

6 thoughts on “By their words shall you know them

  1. Jockanese Wind Talker

    Aye Peter,

    The same Mundell who said “Scotland ceased to exist and was absorbed by England after the Act of Union 1707” but still took the Scottish Secretary’s job and pay rise that went with it.

    It is all “Post truth” politics (lies reported as fact, facts omitted).

    Little wonder Chief Media Officer at the Scotland Office is Magnus Gardham.

    The First Minister is not a “prisoner of her own party” she is a prisoner of fate.

    A fate who’s circumstances are now squarely at the feet of the Conservative and Unionist Party and their Brexit experiment.

  2. Papadox

    Excellent believe every word you say Peter but could never have put it into words. Thank you. I believe the state secret agencies are now in gear and ramping things up to order by the nasty Teresa May. As I have said previously May is a ringer for Rosa KLEBB. A truly nasty person IMHO. We really need to be prepared for anything that they throw at us, because it is coming.

  3. James Cassidy

    It seems clear to me that for all their words to the contrary the three Unionist parties are not representing Scotland in the union, quite the reverse. They represent the union in Scotland. They are ambassadors for Britain, they sell Britishness to us. They want us to be regionalised and marginalised. They are in effect “so-called Scots”, who will say they are Scottish while doing everything to the contrary. Their every utterance is to play down Scotland’s potential, to spread the message that we, among all the other nations on the planet are unfit to look after ourselves and that we need London to do that for us. They exemplify the “proud Scot but” mentality, where no matter what this country achieves it’s never quite good enough.
    https://anindependentscotsman.wordpress.com/2016/09/06/so-called-scots/

  4. Georgia Dickerman

    I read this most interesting piece and at first I thought I was reading about the newly elected President here in the United States. Of course after reading further I realized that it concerned current events there in Scotland. Believe me when I tell you that I understand what you are going through, and although I have never been blind to the fact that all politicians lie at one time or another, never has it been so clear and discernible. My spirit is with you all in your struggle. It seems to be of epidemic proportions in this world. All we can do is stand tall, strong and resist until righteousness is restored!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com